On Jan. 21, 2009, the United States Supreme Court, in Locke v. Karass,1 upheld the constitutionality of a union’s use of service fees paid by nonunion employees for litigation outside the local union chapter’s jurisdiction. Prior to Locke, there was an uncertainty among federal courts as to whether, or when, the First Amendment, permits charging nonunion members for the cost of national litigation. Supreme Court precedents had established that public sector unions violated the First Amendment when they charged nonmembers for expenses related to political activities, whereas charging nonmembers for expenses not directly related to the union local were constitutionally permissible under other circumstances.